"You can get anything in this world if you genuinely don't want it" - George Orwell
Last month, on the Thames Path, some of us visited George Orwell's grave. Betwist Xmas and New Year this year I'm running a London by Foot walk based around Orwell and London locations pertinent to him. Without giving it too much thought, I decided to call the walk Keep The Aspidistra Flying because (1) it's set in London and (2) it sounds good.
The trouble is I'd not actually read Keep The Aspidistra Flying so I thought I ought to remedy that forthwith. Orwell's good so surely it would be a pleasure rather than a chore. That's what I thought. It turned out I was right. It was an immensely easy, and enjoyable, read and even, towards the end, quite an emotional one. If not in the way I'd expected.
Twenty-nine year old Gordon Comstock (a cipher for Orwell himself?) is struggling with money, his clothes are tatty with buttons missing, and he can barely afford cigarettes. The bookshop, McKechnie's, he works in is quiet and full of second hand books nobody wants to read, let alone buy. Comstock seems filled with contempt for everything around him.
The books, the advertising hoardings, the customers at McKechnie's, the cinema ("why encourage the art that is destined to replace literature?"), and, with a passion, the "snooty young men from Cambridge". More than anything it seems, he has contempt for himself. He's not a man who takes pleasure on seeing his own reflection in a mirror. He'd written a book some years ago but it had sold very poorly. Which had only compounded his poverty and his love/hate relationship with money. A theme his mind endlessly returns to. He hates money but he needs it. He certainly hates other people having money.
He blamed money for the fact that Rosemary refused to convert their very close friendship into a romantic and physical relationship (despite his repeated attempts to browbeat her into it, and the fact that she is genuinely interested in him) and he blamed money for his inability to build a closer friendship with the charming, and rich, Ravelston, editor of something called Antichrist. Ravelston proved himself to be sympathetic to Comstock and well meaning although that could hardly be said for his girlfriend Hermione who considered the lower classes to be "absolutely disgusting".
Comstock shares his lodgings with roly-poly George Flaxman, a lascivious toilet accessory salesman temporarily estranged from his wife, and Lorenheim, a desperate loner full of tall tales of improbable seductions and equally unlikely cunning ruses. The time he, Comstock, spends there is either spent feeling sorry for himself or working on his epic poem London Pleasures. But he isn't really getting anywhere with the latter of those pursuits.
Yet he perseveres. As if writing it could save him from poverty and social isolation. Night after night spent in his "lonely room" with its "womanless bed". Just dust, fag ash, and aspidistra leaves for company. He'd become interested in aspidistras after reading The Ragged Trouser Philanthropist. Aspidistras, for Gordon Comstock, should be on the coat of arms instead of the lion and the unicorn. There would be no revolution in England while there are aspidistras in the windows.
Comstock had tried what passed for normality - feeling he owed it to his mother - but though he was perfectly competent at performing his job he was unhappy in his work and when his mother died he walked out of the company. Actual poverty didn't suit him as well as he thought so, after draining his poor sister Julia's money pot, he eventually took another well paid job at the New Albion Publicity Company which would breed in him his utter contempt for any form of advertising, "the dirtiest ramp that capitalism has yet produced".
Although he did meet the "distinctly attractive but rather intimidating" (his words, she's actually incredibly generous and thoughtful as well as extremely fond of him) Rosemary there and, which satisfied him less, turned out to be rather good at "writing lies to tickle the money out of fools' pockets". But that wasn't the life that Gordon Comstock wanted. He wanted a job that would "keep his body without wholly buying his soul" and, on top of that, Comstock felt the world revolved around him. When things went badly, which to his mind they almost always did, he would fall into a vortex of despair. A very well articulated vortex of despair of course.
Comstock turns up to a party that's been cancelled, he receives a rejection letter from one of the periodicals he'd hoped would publish him, and, for the most part, he can't even afford to drown his sorrows. So Gordon Comstock walks the streets of London alone at night and imagines the future. It's not a pretty future. Gordon Comstock rarely seems to try to alter the course of his own destiny. Like so many before and after him.
At times, Gordon Comstock doesn't sound like the sort of person you'd want to be around. He imagines every life lived in London to be "meaningless and intolerable", he sees decay, desolation, and disintegration everywhere he looks. Future wars and suicides seem, to him, inevitable and unavoidable. To be fair, the book was written in 1936 so it wasn't a bad call.
The era it is set in (Lyons tea houses, Player's Weights cigarettes, threepenny-bits, 7p pints in pubs with sawdust on their floors) is long gone and some of the language hasn't aged well either. (the girl serving Comstock in the shop is a "little bitch", an Italian girl is a "tart" (that one's meant as a compliment), an effeminate man is a "Nancy", and an Indian man is a "curry-face") but, elsewhere, the minutiae of life is incredibly well observed. There's a crack in the ceiling above Gordon Comstock's bed that resembles a map of Australia, and there's a "strange listless feeling" on Sunday night "when people are more tired after a day of idleness than a day of work".
It's worth observing that Orwell himself, like Comstock, uses the book to take pot shots at some of his own favourite targets. Chief among them the middle classes of England who lack vitality and die of dingy but expensive diseases often in the overfilled mental hospitals of our benighted nation. "Pretentious and wretched public schools" come in to Orwell's/Comstock's cross hairs too. Unsurprisingly.
Equally unsurprisingly, Gordon Comstock's relentless negativity, selfishness, and stubborn nature result in his life slowly falling apart and inevitable spirals of despair and degradation starting to appear. Even when he, quite against type, comes into some money he squanders it in the most foolish, seedy, and pompous way imaginable. Yet, despite his faults - of which there are many, you find yourself hoping he'll pull himself out of the hole, hoping he'll stick with the writing, and hoping he can learn to treat Rosemary with the respect she deserves and even, just possibly, win her heart over. You'll have to read the book to find out if any of that happens or not and I'd recommend that, if you haven't already, you do just that.
It's a compelling, and addictive, read but, as the critic Cyril Connolly said at the time, it is a "savage and bitter book" that at times makes the reader feel as if they are "in a dentist's chair with the drill whirring". That said, Gordon Comstock's motivations are relatable. Like many an idealistic yet selfish young man, he rails against respectability (those aspidistras again) and worship of Mammon. He would rather "reign in hell than serve in heaven".
In some ways, he's like an overgrown manchild prototype for J. D. Salinger's Holden Caulfield (who appeared a decade and a half later). In more worrying ways he's sometimes like an early version of an incel ("she would never understand. No woman ever understands", women were "a bloody curse"), and, in ways that are far easier to empathise and identify with, simply a frustrated writer, a frustrated poet, a frustrated artist, and a frustrated person. Like so many before and after him.